|
|
|
||||||
|
Top Stories 27th
Annual Convention (7/25/08)
Convention
Lecture Legislation Journal
of the American Naturopathic Medical Association (JANMA) Facts |
ANMA Embroidered Polo Shirts in Black and White Naturopathy, New Products & Research (following the recent ANMA Convention in Las Vegas) A Call For Validated Research Papers To
advertise in the ANMA Monitor or ANMA MONITOR ONLINE
Please take the time to look over our sponsors!
The President's Corner As I begin this brief message I am reminded of a quote "There is so much good in the worst of us, and so much bad in the best of us, that it hardly behooves any of us to talk about the rest of us". As we approach the end of 2002 it is time to look forward to the coming year. Since it’s the holiday season and a time for joy – let’s not take this time to dwell on the coming year, except to say each one of us will have to work hard in their respective state if unfair legislation is introduced. Each of you should acquaint yourself with the political process and know how to express yourself to insure that unfair legislation is not passed. Having made that brief statement let me just take this opportunity to say that all of us at ANMA hope you and your loved ones enjoyed a very nice Thanksgiving and realize that there is much to be thankful for. With the approaching holidays we want to wish you the very best holiday season and remind you to share your happiness and joy with others. Take time also to mark you calendar for July 18-20, 2003 to enjoy fellowship at the ANMA annual convention. Season Greetings and Best Wishes for the New Year.
California and the Future of Naturopathy By: Robert J Thiel, Ph.D., Naturopath
On September 23, 2002, California Governor Gray Davis signed Senate Bill 577, which is effective January 1, 2003. This bill indicates, with mandated disclosures, that the practice of alternative and complementary health modalities (such as naturopathy) does not violate various medical statutes. I personally was neutral towards the bill. This bill, which is similar (but much less complicated) to one passed in the State of Minnesota a few years ago, seems to be the continuation of a trend that began in 1994 when the Federal District of Columbia re-instated its practice of registering traditional naturopaths. After its preamble, SB 577 states: SEC. 2. Section 2053.5 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read: 2053.5. (a) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a person who complies with the requirements of Section 2053.6 shall not be in violation of Section 2051, 2052, or 2053 unless that person does any of the following: (1) Conducts surgery or any other procedure on another person that punctures the skin or harmfully invades the body. (2) Administers or prescribes X-ray radiation to another person. (3) Prescribes or administers legend drugs or controlled substances to another person. (4) Recommends the discontinuance of legend drugs or controlled substances prescribed by an appropriately licensed practitioner. (5) Willfully diagnoses and treats a physical or mental condition of any person under circumstances or conditions that cause or create a risk of great bodily harm, serious physical or mental illness, or death. (6) Sets fractures. (7) Treats lacerations or abrasions through electrotherapy. (8) Holds out, states, indicates, advertises, or implies to a client or prospective client that he or she is a physician, a surgeon, or a physician and surgeon. (b) A person who advertises any services that are not unlawful under Section 2051, 2052, or 2053 pursuant to subdivision (a) shall disclose in the advertisement that he or she is not licensed by the state as a healing arts practitioner. SEC. 3. Section 2053.6 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read: 2053.6. (a) A person who provides services pursuant to Section 2053.5 that are not unlawful under Section 2051, 2052, or 2053 shall, prior to providing those services, do the following: (1) Disclose to the client in a written statement using plain language the following information: (A) That he or she is not a licensed physician. (B) That the treatment is alternative or complementary to healing arts services licensed by the state. (C) That the services to be provided are not licensed by the state. (D) The nature of the services to be provided. (E) The theory of treatment upon which the services are based. (F) His or her educational, training, experience, and other qualifications regarding the services to be provided. (2) Obtain a written acknowledgement from the client stating that he or she has been provided with the information described in paragraph (1). The client shall be provided with a copy of the written acknowledgement, which shall be maintained by the person providing the service for three years. (b) The information required by subdivision (a) shall be provided in a language that the client understands. (c) Nothing in this section or in Section 2053.5 shall be construed to do the following: (1) Affect the scope of practice of licensed physicians and surgeons. (2) Limit the right of any person to seek relief for negligence or any other civil remedy against a person providing services subject to the requirements of this section." As can be seen above, this new California law specifically prohibits unlicensed practitioners (such as naturopaths) from performing surgery or becoming involved with controlled substances, such as prescription medications. This is consistent with traditional naturopathy. Dr. Benedict Lust, the initiator of modern American naturopathy (naturopathy had always existed in America, but it had not been referred to by that name, nor were there formal naturopathic associations, prior to Dr. Lust), declared, "Naturopathy is not in the practice of medicine or surgery...All the methods of a Naturopathy are natural methods, the agents of life such as food, air, sun, exercises, relaxation, sleep, the use of herbs" (Wendell P. Standardized Naturopathy: The Science and Art of Natural Healing, 1951). The Congressional Record reports, Naturopathy does not contemplate drugs or surgical operations, nor is it within the scope of their science of practice. To the contrary, they do not use or prescribe drugs as part of their treatment, nor do they advocate or perform surgical operations on their patients (Langley, Katherine. Congressional Record, February 7, 1931). Naturopathy is based on the healing power of nature, vis medicatrix naturae (American Naturopathic Medical Association Code of Ethics, 1996). In spite of dozens of misguided bills, since 1996 no state has enacted legislation to allow ‘CNME’ naturopaths to practice their distorted view of naturopathy (their view is distorted because many CNME types seem to feel that it is necessary to write prescriptions for medication in order to be a naturopath). (CNME stands for the Council on Naturopathic Medical Education. CNME once had federal recognition, but this recognition was withdrawn by the U.S. Secretary of Education, based on reports which indicated that CNME violated its own ‘standards’ and participated in activities which I consider fraudulent. This article will refer to supporters and graduates of CNME approved schools as CNME types or something similar.) It should be noted that the bill that passed in Kansas in 2002 was only a registration bill and does not provide what the CNME types have tried to attain.
Why Neutrality? Since the California law is consistent with traditional naturopathy, some may ask why I personally was neutral towards SB 577? The reason is that while it is good that legislators acknowledge that we naturopaths are not violating any medical statutes by practicing traditional naturopathy, this law and others like it, may not result in the type of profession that many of us naturopathic doctors ultimately hope to have. Another reason was that the bill was changed a few times and I had questions about at least one of the bill’s initial supporters. Also, the bill did not (and does not) specifically include the term ‘naturopathy’. In addition, once the bill was amended and finalized, SB 577 mandated (through the additions of B&P codes 2053.5 and 2053.6) disclosure paperwork and also requires that any person who advertises services that are not unlawful...shall disclose in the advertisement that he or she is not licensed by the state as a healing arts professional. Thus SB 577 may have the effect of placing advertisements for naturopathic services in a competitive disadvantage to acupuncturists, massage therapists, chiropractors, and others who sometimes also provide naturopathic services as they will not have to state that they are unlicensed healing arts professionals. On the other hand, SB 577 essentially does re-establish California’s official recognition of drugless health professionals and our right to provide drugless treatments. And unlike the Minnesota bill, SB 577 does not specifically prohibit alternative and complementary health professionals from using the term doctor. Furthermore, and although I am not a lawyer, it seems to me that the final version of SB 577 gives naturopathic practitioners in California rights comparable to those held by naturopaths in Alaska, Hawaii, Maine, Montana, New Hampshire, Vermont, and the District of Columbia (but without requiring actual licensing/registration). However, SB 577 does not mention any standard for calling oneself a naturopathic doctor. When I was the president of the California State Naturopathic Medical Association (CSNMA), I negotiated with the then three schools which had approval by the Bureau for Private Postsecondary and Vocational Education of the Department of Consumer Affairs of the State of California to provide training in naturopathy (International College of Naturopathy, International College of Healing Arts, Gateway College of Naturopathy and Naturopathic Therapeutics, and California Naturopathic College) to agree to the same set of standards for our profession--eventually all those schools agreed to the same standards. On April 28, 2000, I sent a copy of those standards to the Bureau for Private Postsecondary and Vocational Education of the Department of Consumer Affairs of the State of California, and those standards have acted as the de facto standards in California. Those standards list scope of practice, the fact that anyone (no matter how trained) should be allowed to use the term naturopath, and also lists academic (and other standards) for calling oneself a naturopathic doctor (or naturopathic physician). The scope of practice in those standards is consistent with SB 577, including the allopathic restrictions.
‘CNME’ Naturopaths May Have a Different Agenda On January 31, 2001, as president of the CSNMA, I drove a few hundred miles to meet with Angela Burr-Madsen (president of the California Naturopathic Association, CNA) and Sally LaMont (executive director of the California Association of Naturopathic Physicians, CANP--a CNME type group). The intent of the meeting was for the different naturopathic groups to share their positions and see where there might be any common ground. At that meeting, I discussed naturopathy in the State of California and the standards that the majority of naturopaths within the State believed and practiced. Dr. LaMont discussed what CANP wanted. Dr. Madsen discussed CNA’s positions on various aspects of naturopathy, including legislative matters. I told Dr. LaMont that if her organization wanted naturopathic standards, title protection, hospital privileges, insurance reimbursement, and the right to diagnose, that they should support CSNMA--I proposed what standards, etc. that others in California had accepted and urged CANP to adopt them as well. However, Dr. LaMont wanted CANP to have what I considered to be a disproportionate voice in determining the education and other standards for naturopaths in California. I told her in no uncertain terms that that would not be acceptable. I also told her that most traditional naturopathic doctors did not trust CANP, would not allow CANP to control the determination of naturopathic standards, and that we would remain adamantly opposed to naturopaths practicing medicine through prescriptions and elective surgeries. Dr. LaMont then challenged my statement that historically naturopaths in California were not engaged in prescription medicine and non-emergency surgery, so I told her that I would send her an article documenting the history of naturopathy in California. Suffice it for brevity’s sake to quote Dr. Benedict Lust on this matter in California, "there was an element, which...were giving narcotics, prescribing liquors, performing major and minor operations...bringing ill repute on the proud and clean name of Naturopathy....If members of our Association insist on practicing medicine, either legally or illegally, why not join the AMA and be done with them" (Lust, B. A Report on Conditions in California. The Naturopath, May 1923, pp.250-251). He also stated, "In view of the discriminatory mandates in force by the adherents of the Medical Trust, the domination of certain public officials and the existing rules of insurance companies and other semi-public institutions, it is absolutely necessary that a Naturopath should be designated also as a Physician and Surgeon. Only through this addition to their title are the non-drug healers enabled to obtain the legitimate privileges covered by law. Without the rather strange appendages aforesaid, Naturopaths are deprived of many rights - they could not sign birth or death certificates, assist in compensation insurance matters, arrange sick fund papers, testify in courts of law as qualified physicians and practice in hospitals and public institutions generally. I am with the very honest effort in California to raise the Naturopathic (non-drug) profession to a higher standard of service. I am with every progressive movement to fit Naturopaths to take the place of Medical doctors and fake Osteopathic Surgeons. California has always been a pioneering State and is a community well suited through tradition and learning to take the initiative. I am whole-heartedly with the progressive Naturopaths of California. My acquiescence in the terms of Physicians and Surgeons as attached to Naturopathy applies only to California and not to those States where Naturopathy is not discriminated against and where the Naturopaths do not have to face such rigid and relentless laws and peculiar local conditions as they do in California. The above distinction I wish to emphasize emphatically at this time in order to avoid any misunderstanding of my position in the future." Sadly, many CNME types have apparently misunderstood his position. He further stated, "In closing I will say that Naturopathy - true Naturopathy - is summed up in its recognized definition as embraced in the special law of Congress of February, 1929. In conformity with this definition are the curriculums of all true Naturopathic schools made. It is the basis for all legislation and our strong line of defense. To the terms of this definition must we adjust our practices. Remember: Naturopaths are Doctors - minus Materia Medica and Surgery." I have found that, as a group, CNME naturopaths are not particularly knowledgeable about the history of naturopathy in the U.S. when naturopathy was specifically recognized by most states (1910-1940). They seem to feel that the profession evolved from one limited to natural methods to one that includes allopathic methods--even though those two philosophies are for the most part diametrically opposed to one another. Actually, in my opinion, the main reason that naturopathy has had problems throughout its U.S. history is precisely because there has always been a small element calling themselves naturopaths which have insisted on using allopathic, instead of naturopathic, modalities. Dr. LaMont also stated that although only a minority of her members wanted to perform surgery or prescribe medications, that CANP would always insist on ultimately incorporating those modalities (CNME types call this ‘their full scope of practice’ or ‘practicing to the full extent of their education’).
CSNMA Proposal to CANP and CNA During the meeting, I proposed the following to Dr. LaMont: If her organization would cease to introduce restrictive bills, would support only naturopathic modalities for naturopathic doctors (i.e. no prescription medications or non-emergency surgery), and back the CSNMA, then the CSNMA would: 1) Insist on the following three standards for one to use the title ‘naturopathic doctor’: a. A minimum of a seven-year education standard b. The completion of a clinical naturopathic internship c. Successful passing of a national, truly naturopathic, board certification examination. 2) Allow CANP and its affiliates to have input on the aforementioned standards. 3) Allow CNA to have input on the aforementioned standards. 4) Work to allow naturopathic doctors to bill insurance companies. 5) Work to allow naturopathic doctors to diagnose and treat. 6) Work to allow recognition as primary (natural) care doctors/physicians (allowing physical examinations, etc.). 7) Work to allow naturopathic doctors to have hospital privileges. 8) Work for State recognition of naturopathic certification. 9) Not oppose naturopathic licensure based on the above. 10) Not discriminate against CNME or CNA naturopaths. 11) Allow naturopaths who did not meet the standards in 1) above to continue to practice naturopathy, but without using the term ‘naturopathic doctor’ or ‘naturopathic physician’. I explained that if all groups truly wanted unity within the profession, that this was the time to go forward, as the other alternative was legislation similar to that which had been enacted in Minnesota. I explained that it was my strong opinion that CNME restrictive legislation had no chance to pass in California. I also explained that the insistence of CNME naturopaths to practice non-naturopathic modalities (prescription drugs and non-emergency surgeries) had excessively provoked the medical community and that the medical establishment would work its hardest to not allow any type of naturopathic standard (or licensure) which allowed naturopaths to practice allopathic medicine. Dr. Burr-Madsen said she felt my proposal was something that CNA could enthusiastically support. When the meeting ended, Dr. LaMont promised to go to her organization, discuss my proposal, and provide a response. About one month later, I called CANP president David Field. Dr. Field knew nothing of my proposal, but seemed interested and said someone would get back to me. No one ever did. In June 2001, while at a health convention, I happen to run across Dr. LaMont. I reminded her that I had not heard from her. She told me that I had offered her nothing and that essentially that CANP would pursue legislation on its own. I was somewhat surprised. When I talk to the average CNME-type naturopath, most tell me that all they want is a legitimate standard for calling oneself a naturopath doctor, the ability to diagnose & treat, the ability to bill insurance companies, and hopefully have hospital privileges and be recognized as ‘primary care’ providers. While that may be what the average CNME school graduate wants, that seems to differ widely from what their leadership seems to want--control of the profession, prescription drug rights, and surgery procedures. (Perhaps it should be mentioned here that I stepped down as CSNMA president in June 2001 due to family considerations, and the California voice of the American Naturopathic Medical Association-ANMA became the Naturopathic Medical Association of California-NMAC, with Dr. Raj Pal as president.)
What Happened Next Later, CNME naturopaths sent copies of the September 2001 Profile of a Profession: Naturopathic Practice to many politicians, including several in California. This report, which was funded by a grant from the Arkay Foundation, which appeared to have had ties with one or more CNME-related groups, erroneously seems to categorized naturopaths into two categories--those who went to CNME type schools and those who went to distance learning programs--it barely mentions that there are non-CNME residential naturopathic schools with State approvals and never mentions that at least one non-CNME residential naturopathic university has a Federal charter. Although it included some good information, I consider Profile of a Profession: Naturopathic Practice to be of questionable value as it did not include information on real naturopathic standards, basically ignored the history of naturopathy, did not explain that many of the problems in the profession have to do with naturopathic vs. allopathic modalities, did not explain many relevant details about CNME’s questionable practices, etc. (e.g. it left out, for example, the January 16, 2001 letter from the US Secretary of Education explaining why CNME was denied recognition as a nationally recognized accrediting agency). The report left out information from an interview Dr. Holly Hough (a report author) initiated with Dr. William von Peters of First National University of Naturopathy, where he explained that the rift in the profession was not simply one of education, but between naturopaths and allopathic wannabes (it left out similar interview information from me). The report left out the standards that existed in California (even though they were sent to one of the main authors of the report). The report even had the gall to suggest that only CNME types are contributing to ‘organized’ naturopathic research. Another funny thing about this distorted report is that in 1999 CANP tried to get the California Senate to do this type of report, but CANP had the bill die (after it was amended) when it was clear that CANP would not be able to control the report (CANP wanted California to do a report about other CNME states, whereas the bill had been amended to primarily report on naturopathic education and practices within California). CANP then attempted to get the California Department of Consumer Affairs to do a similar report, but the Department wisely refused. So I guess if you can not get the government to do something directly, getting a school to accept a grant to produce a paid ‘independent’ report is what you do.
In 2002 and Beyond In 2002, CANP introduced a CNME restrictive naturopathic licensure bill in California, which as I predicted failed. In 2002, SB 577 (which was similar, but better, than the law in Minnesota) passed, as I indicated that it would. In late 2002, I heard a report that CANP got Senator Perata to agree to introduce another CNME restrictive naturopathic licensure bill. This is to be introduced in the California State Senate in 2003. Although Senator Perata has a reputation as an astute senator when it comes to bill introduction, my sources have suggested that the State of California is nowhere near serious about any CNME restrictive naturopathic licensure bill for four reasons: 1) SB 577 was recently signed and many legislators believe that this solves the need to do anything about ‘alternative and complementary medicine’ for quite a few years. 2) The California Medical Board is strongly opposed to naturopathic licensure, especially that which is espoused by the CANP (California medical doctors became quite alarmed when CNME types tried to get broader prescription drug rights, such as injectable narcotics, in the States of Washington and Oregon in 1999--they failed to get those ‘rights’ as the legislative branches of both States refused their requests). 3) There is no additional money for a separate naturopathic board due to the State of California’s current budget problems. 4) The facts about why CNME recently lost its federal recognition as an accrediting agency should make any legislative branch wary of providing these graduates their own license in the foreseeable future. So what is the future? The future remains unknown, but there are several possibilities. Since California is the biggest state in the U.S., it is likely that other states will follow the lead of California and adopt improved Minnesota-like bills. These type of bills will be backed by groups such as the Coalition for Natural Health as well as some of the distance learning naturopathic schools. These bills may pretty much eliminate the possibility of CNME naturopaths getting passed the types of bills they have consistently failed to get since 1996. As long as CNME-types continue to teach naturopathic students allopathic modalities and to push for prescription drugs and non-emergency surgery rights, the medical boards of all the states will continue to strongly oppose them. Battles will continue. Furthermore, since on June 21, 2002, the State of Connecticut reaffirmed that graduates of one non-CNME school (First National University of Naturopathy) are eligible for licensure, this ultimately may mean that CNME graduates will not be the only naturopaths legally allowed in the eleven or twelve states which currently have that type of restriction. Perhaps those states will ultimately decide that only naturopathic modalities will be allowed (actually that is the case in one-half of the CNME licensed states currently). At present, however, CNME types have told the State of Connecticut that they are unwilling to recognize a non-CNME school and have thus far prevented graduates of First National University of Naturopathy from sitting for the licensing exam. It is my opinion that since the State of Connecticut has recently, on several occasions, stated that First National graduates are eligible for licensure, that the CNME dominated testing board will have no choice but to abide by the decision of the State (and its Attorney General who is currently investigating this matter). Disunity will continue to prevail in the profession. Real naturopathic standards will be non-existent in nearly all states. The naturopathic profession will continue to be considered third-rate. As long as some states continue to allow naturopaths to practice allopathic modalities, some naturopaths will continue to delude themselves into believing that they are as trained in medical modalities as medical doctors are. It is possible that with the passage of SB 577 that it is only a matter of time until all states adopt similar laws. It is possible that the damage done to the naturopathic profession by those who insist on doing medical procedures is too great to be overcome. But maybe not.
There Remains Another Option One small possibility, which the CNME naturopathic leadership (defined more broadly than the CNME itself) has consistently opposed (as it has long refused ANMA’s offers towards unification), is that of unifying the profession around reasonable standards. The standards would be built on naturopathic principles (such as those adopted by the majority of the profession in 1947). The standards would include education and certification as the means of differentiating between the differing levels of training amongst naturopaths. Perhaps similar to those which several California schools have adopted and I alluded to earlier. But for that to happen, naturopathic doctors (especially CNME-types) will need to decide that they want to only practice naturopathy. All naturopaths need to realize that there are more than 4-5 schools in the entire world that can teach naturopathy. Naturopathic doctors need to realize that making provisions for variously trained individuals is not detrimental to the profession. Otherwise, the battles will continue into the future. And money which could be spent educating the public on the benefits of naturopathy, as well as for funding naturopathic research, will continue to be wasted in political battles with no likelihood of unifying the profession. These battles should be unnecessary. Those who introduce restrictive naturopathic legislation need to understand that continuing that course of action is detrimental to the future of the profession of being a doctor of naturopathy. Nearly 90 years ago Benedict Lust wrote, "Let us organize every drugless movement into one body and line up and go forward under the banner of Naturopathy" (Naturopathic News. The Naturopath, November 1914, p. 756). Those who believe they should prescribe drugs should not use the term naturopathy--they should not be under that naturopathy banner! Those who believe in true naturopathy should support the ANMA. ANMA (along with ANCB) is the main national group I am aware of that supports true naturopathic modalities for naturopaths, supports the rights of everyone to practice naturopathy, and has separate standards for those to be certified as naturopathic doctors/physicians. Separation of allopathic wannabes from naturopaths, while uniting all true believers in naturopathy would bring unity to our profession and help insure the future of naturopathy. In this age of unnaturally-processed foods, isn’t that what the residents of California and the other states need?
ANMA Conference: An Oasis in
the Desert Some people like bright lights and big-city energy, others prefer a starry night at Lake Mead National Park. At the 21st annual conference of the American Naturopathic Medical Association, more than 800 experts in natural health and holistic nutrition gathered for three days of educational workshops, product demonstrations and plenty of networking. Whether you seek stimulation via casinos, shopping, musical theatre, floating in a gondola, or deep-breathing in an oxygen chamber, ANMA’s Las Vegas setting offers a rare getaway. CCNH alumni presentations were high on the list of 2002 conference highlights: Cory Carter, ND, Repeated a popular workshop on how to increase lymphatic flow to aid in natural detoxification and to enhance healing; Richard Drucker, PhD and ND, returned to lead a session on fulvic acid ; Danielle Duperret, ND, demonstrated biofeedback methods of balancing harmonic (sound) and photonic (light) energies within the body; and Tom Wu, PhD, led two seminars on alternative approaches to bursitis, the second of which doubled as a fundraiser for ANMA legislative fund. After the second day of classes, approximately 100 CCNH students and graduates from coast-to coast gathered for a private reception hosted by their alma mater. Escaping the crowded conference and exhibition halls, attendees ascended to a penthouse view at sunset for some healthy refreshments and heart-to-heart connecting with classmates. Clayton College vice president Kay Channell, admissions coordinator Lisa Blackmon, admissions advisor Jim Farmer, academics director Linda Powell, alumni director Susie Hale, marketing director Judy Williams, and communications director Mary Grace McCord enjoyed getting to know students, answering questions and helping to facilitate discussions. As is often the case when healthy, happy people gather to socialize, the group energy shifted easily between inquisitive conversation, laughter, healthy snacking, and even a bit of singing and dancing. If you didn’t make it to ANMA this time, CCNH hopes to meet you there next year. Mark your calendars now for the July 18-20, 2003 conference in Las Vegas, and for our second-annual alumni reception.
ANMA Embroidered Polo Shirts
Are Here! Dear ANMA Members, As you may already know, ANMA began offering embroidered polo shirts earlier this year. What you probably don’t know, is that we now offer the polo shirts in black. The quality of the black polo shirt is even better than previous shirts. The original white polo shirts, as I’ve said before look absolutely beautiful, but the black polo shirts have a different uniqueness that makes having both a must. I promise you will be very pleased with these polo shirts. ANMA offers nothing but the best quality to its valued members. I guarantee that every order will be processed and mailed as quickly as possible. All shirts will be shipped Priority Mail to ensure speedy delivery. ANMA can offer these polo shirts to members for only $25.00 plus shipping and handling. The sizes we have range from small to triple extra large. If you would like a 2xl or 3xl, please add $1.00 and $2.00 respectively. I’m not the only one who thinks the ANMA polo
shirts look beautiful: If you have any questions or want to place an order, e-mail me at: gregorywest@anma.com or call Julie Morgan at (702) 897-7053 or mail to ANMA, P.O. Box 96273, Las Vegas, Nv. 89193. Thanks for all of your support. Sincerely,
Parkinson's Disease By: Vladimir Badmaev, M.D. Ph.D.
In the early 19th century James Parkinson characterized a shaking palsy as a unique condition, now known as Parkinson’s disease (PD), a condition affecting more than one million people in the U.S. alone. Parkinson’s disease often dawns in the prime of life, in people 50-60 years old, and progressively leads to physical incapacitation. Ironically, the disease quite often strikes very energetic, self-made and self-reliant individuals. The hesitant and uncoordinated walking, perceived "heaviness of legs", slowness of body movements, occasional loss of balance and dizziness, slurred speech and deteriorating handwriting are the classic beginnings of this disease and may initially improve after a good night’s rest. These symptoms, however, may be overlooked by the patient or even dismissed as "simple exhaustion" due to a busy and stressful pace of life. If left untreated, the disease can gradually take over a patient’s physical capacity, and to a lesser degree, mental abilities within a few short years from the time of first clinical onset. Typically, PD patients may present themselves with a tremor, e.g. "pill-rolling" movements of the thumb and index finger and/or rhythmical head movements; rigidity (muscular stiffness) on passive motion, so called "lead-pipe" or "cogwheel" symptoms; a slow, shuffling gait; an expressionless, mask-like face and speaking softly in an impatient, rapid and illegible way. In advanced Parkinson’s disease, motor disturbances may become more pronounced by a so called freezing of gait, or the patient’s momentary inability to make a single step forward despite the fact that one’s will is screaming and urging to do so. A "freezer" would report the experience as a situation of "legs getting stuck to the ground while trying to walk." Somatic symptoms like fatigue, constipation, headache, insomnia, loss of appetite, dizziness and sweating are not unusual for a patient with PD. These symptoms may occur early on in PD, and may re present the autonomic nervous system failure caused by the disease. The most common symptoms of autonomic dysfunction in PD patients include erectile dysfunction, sensation of incomplete bladder emptying, urgency, constipation, difficulty in swallowing, and dizziness upon standing up or after a meal. In one clinical evaluation eighty-nine percent of PD patients had at least one of these autonomic symptoms, compared to 43% of healthy control subjects. Parkinson’s patients often experience disturbances of an emotional and psychiatric nature. Feelings of hopelessness, persistent fatigue, insomnia and mental depression are some of the most common emotional and psychiatric complications of this disease. Cognitive deficits are observed frequently and in fact can be noticed in the early stages of PD. However, these deficits do not mean that intellectual efficiency and status are necessarily in a state of decline. In fact, typically only selective memory functions are impaired in PD in both short and long-term memory. Patients would still be able to learn or acquire new mental and motor information, but have difficulty in utilizing this information properly and in a timely manner. As a result, the adaptive behavior needed to respond to challenging situations that require problem-solving skills and planning abilities, is affected in PD. For example, the task of driving a car may be seriously impeded by these cognitive disturbances. Although the patients may have difficulty in retrieving and using memory, impaired memory functions are not permanently lost and can be significantly improved by cueing. Therefore a deficit in imbibing new information, considered to be a hallmark for the diagnosis of dementia, is not present in most PD cases and most patients have preserved intellectual abilities.
CAUSE AND MECHANISM OF PD Parkinson’s disease is characterized by a marked decrease in the number of dopaminergic neurons in the brain (nigrostriatal area) and decline in levels of dopamine, a neurohormone and a transmitter of neuronal impulses. The exact cause(s) leading to this PD pathology is still unknown except in the case of genetically conditioned autosomal recessive juvenile disease. This disease leads to massive and rapid loss of dopaminergic neurons usually in patients in their 20s. It has been recognized that oxidative (free-radical) injury to the dopaminergic neuron mitochondria leads to neuronal cell degeneration and premature cell death. Both mitochondria) mutations in juvenile PD and/or biological and chemical toxic agents have been demonstrated to cause oxidative injury to the mitochondria, and auto oxidation of dopamine, with resulting dopaminergic neuron degeneration. The idiopathic PD, which usually affects people in their 50s and 60s, has been linked with long term occupational exposure to pesticides (no association with specific pesticide(s) could be detected), as a complication of epidemic encephalitis, vascular disorders (atherosclerosis of brain circulation), infectious diseases (neurosyphilis, herpes, flu virus), and following head trauma (for example, in professional boxers).
MANAGEMENT AND TREATMENT The pharmacological treatment of PD is based on drugs that prevent destruction of dopaminergic neurons, and to supply the disease depleted neurohormone dopamine to the central nervous system (CNS), as well as restore balance in the neurohormones and functioning of the CNS. While synthetic drugs are conventionally used in the management of PD, there are several plant-derived nutraceutical compounds, which may potentially be useful as a nutritional complement to the basic treatment. Mucuna pruriens (from the botanical family Fabaceae, commonly known as velvet bean or cowitch) is a medicinal plant known from the traditional medical system of India, Ayurveda (Ayur – of life; Veda – science or knowledge). The beans of Mucuna pruriens contain a approximately 3% of levodopa or L-DOPA, a parent compound and the metabolic precursor of dopamine, the neurohormone that is deficient in PD patients. In a synthetic form, levodopa has been used in treatment of PD since the 1960s. Interestingly, the oral administration of dopamine was found ineffective in treatment of PD, because in this form, the neurohormone does not cross the blood-brain barrier and is inaccessible to the central nervous system. However, levodopa does cross the blood-brain barrier and once in the CNS it is converted to dopamine. The problem is that the bioavailable oral levodopa is also readily converted into dopamine prior to crossing the blood-brain barrier. To overcome this undesired effect the drug is either given in large doses, or administered together with cardidopa, a compound that inhibits the conversion (process of decarboxylation) of levodopa into dopamine outside the CNS. This way more levodopa is available for crossing from the blood to the brain and subsequently more dopamine is made available in the neurohormone depleted CNS of the PD patient. Interestingly, the extract of Mucuna pruriens beans standardized for levodopa and studied clinically in a relatively small oral dose, improved significantly the condition of PD patients. The researchers in this study postulated that the efficacy of the extract could be attributed to the natural levodopa, as well as other natural substances with a mechanism similar to that of carbidopa. Some research reports mention that levodopa derived from Mucuna pruriens could be two to three times more effective than equivalent amounts of synthetic levodopa. In addition, the natural levodopa was found better tolerated than the synthetic drug with fewer gastrointestinal side effects in the form of nausea and vomiting. The advantage of a lower therapeutic dose of levodopa is also due to potentially lower amounts of peripheral dopamine outside of the CNS. Excessive peripheral dopamine may contribute to gastrointestinal side effects as well as dizziness, drop in blood pressure and tremors. In summary, recent clinical studies support the safety and efficacy of Mucuna pruriens in the management of PD symptoms. Other phytonutrients that could potentially provide nutritional support to PD patients belong to the class of steroidal saponins and could be used alone or in conjunction with Mucuna pruriens in formulations. One herbal source of steroidal saponins, Bacopa monniera (fam. Scrophulariaceae), deserves particular mention. Bacopa monniera has been used in the long-standing Ayurvedic tradition as a "memory tonic" and is traditionally known as Brahmi. Bacopa monniera was evaluated in a four-week treatment of anxiety neurosis patients. The mean anxiety level, maladjustment level, mental fatigue rate, and immediate memory span scores were significantly improved as a result of the treatment. In addition, the four-week therapy resulted in a significant decrease in the systolic blood pressure and a significant increase in overall physical activity, with reported relief from symptoms associated with mental and emotional stress such as fatigue, irritability, lack of concentration and insomnia. Based on summaries from available peer-reviewed studies, the memory enhancing effects of Bacopa monniera and possible complementary action relevant to the mechanism of PD could be due to its modifying effects on the GABA-nergic system (system involved in memory functions), modifying effects on neurotransmitters (glutamate and serotonin), or inhibitory effects on acetylcholinesterase activity (an enzyme destroying neurotransmitter acetylcholine), and anti-inflammatory effects comparable to indomethacin - an anti-inflammatory drug studied in prevention/alleviation of memory loss in Alzheimer’s patients. Based on informal communication from the Central Drug Research Institute (Lucknow, India), the saponin fraction of Bacopa monniera extract may enhance protein kinase C (PKC) that in turn may activate so called neurotrophins. One neurotrophin, nerve growth factor (NGF), has the potential to regenerate neurons. This observation is of interest since levodopa was found to stimulate the human growth factor. It is plausible to research a possible regenerative action of the combination of Mucuna and Bacopa on the CNS in a neurodegenenerative condition like PD. The cumulative mechanism of Bacopa on the central nervous system that is described above may lead to reversal of stress, age and disease like PD related "wear and tear" of neurons. This in turn may lead to improved adaptability or plasticity of neuronal cells and neuronal connections with resulting improvement in CNS functions. Withania somnifera (fam. Solanaceae), especially its roots, known by its Sanskrit name Ashwagandha, is another example of an Ayurved a derived botanical that has potential as a nutritional support to PD patients. This plant has long been used in Ayurveda as a rejuvenative, especially useful in conditions characterized by mental exhaustion, anxiety, mental depression, and chronic disease, e.g. rheumatoid arthritis, ostheoarthritis and diabetes. Ashwagandha was evaluated in several experimental models of stress induced by physical, chemical or psychological factors. In one experiment rodents subjected to physical endurance test were pre-treated with this botanical compound or received a sham treatment only. In comparison to the untreated animals, Ashwagandha prevented stress-related disorders (e.g., enlargement of adrenal glands, and gastrointestinal ulcers), depletion of two important substances in the adrenals, vitamin C and the hormone cortisol, as well as it increased the physical stamina in animals. Ashwagandha, in combination with Mucuna pruriens has also been evaluated for the treatment of depressive illness in twenty-five patients with endogenous and reactive types of depression. The severity of depression and anxiety was evaluated in the course of the two-month study by a self-evaluation scale administered at the beginning, after one month and after two months. A statistically significant improvement in depression and anxiety symptoms scores was noted at the end of the two months compared to the baseline score. Primarily because of its efficacy in stress management Ashwaganda has been named an adaptogen, or a compound credited with exerting a protective effect on the body cells against various stressors. Another botanical employed in traditional Ayurvedic adaptogenic formulations (Rasayanas) is Tribulus terrestris (commonly known as " small caltrops" or "puncture vine", belonging to the natural order Zygophyllaceae). Steroidal saponins (furostanols), identified in the plant extracts are reported to be responsible for the biological effects of the plant. An adaptogen has the following characteristics: 1. Safety of action on the organism; 2. Exhibits a wide range of regulatory activity, but manifesting its action only against the actual challenge to the system; 3. Acts through an increase in a nonspecific adaptation energy (resistance) to harmful influences of an extremely wide spectrum of physical, chemical and biological factors causing stress; 4. Has a normalizing action irrespective of the direction of foregoing pathological changes. Adaptogens could therefore be considered an important part of nutraceutcal and nutritional support in the management of Parkinson’s disease. Lastly, in view of the oxidative and possibly inflammatory mechanisms involved in neuronal degeneration in PD, a group of botanical compounds that function as safe non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) should be considered in nutritional support offered to PD patients. Many of these compounds in addition to their anti-inflammatory action are also versatile antioxidants with two-pronged antioxidant action: preventing free radical formation and intervening to quench existing free radicals. A new class of phytonutrients functioning as NSAIDs and versatile antioxidants is represented by the phenolic compounds forming the natural yellow pigment in Curcuma longa, (turmeric). Known as curcuminoids (curcumin, demethoxycurcumin and bisdemethoxycurcumin) these compounds are reported to be beneficial in inhibiting cellular damage due to free radical pathology. The anti-inflammatory mechanisms of curcuminoids are based on specific inhibition of the enzyme cyclooxygenase type 2 (COX-2), which participates in production of pro-inflammatory prostaglandins including prostaglandin E2 (PG E2). Besides curcuminoids, the botanical compounds known from literature to inhibit the COX-2 enzyme and for their anti-cancer potential are ursolic acid (Rosmarinus officinalis extract), rosmarinic acid (Rosmarinus officinalis extract), gingerols (Zingiber officeinalis extract), and polyphenols (catechins) from green tea (Camelia sinensis extract). Despite our advancing understanding of the pathology of PD, many treatments for this condition date back to the 1960’s and often fall short in bringing significant clinical improvement. The compounds discussed in this article may exemplify a nutritional and nutraceutical approach that may be an important addition to drug therapy to provide adaptogenic and antioxidant support while simultaneously augmenting the patient’s general health status. Besides the "pill" solution an individual patient should take an active role in fighting PD by following: A healthy diet to prevent deterioration of blood circulation in the brain in a similar way as prevention of cardiovascular disease, An active lifestyle involving regular aerobic exercise, and mental exercise keeping the brain creatively occupied for as long in life as possible. The author dedicates this article to his grandparents, Vladimir and Wincenty, who died of Parkinson’s.
Three Faces of Breast Cancer
By: Roy B. Kupsinel, M.D. KUP’S KOMMENT: In medical school and in postgraduate training I was taught to diagnosis diseases and treat with appropriate modalities, especially pharmaceutical prescription drugs. During my evolution as the "Transition Physician" I became more aware that I was dealing with an entire being — physical, mental, emotional and spiritual —and of the need to treat the entire person in what is called the holistic approach. Many alternative physicians use nutritional supplements as substitutes for drugs. They are generally less expensive, much safer, and may be as, or even more, effective than the pharmaceuticals. The medical profession seems to have adopted the term CAM for Complementary and Alternative Medicine and courses are now being offered in many medical schools throughout the country in this field. There is an ever increasing awareness and acceptance of CAM. Many of the nutritional supplements, like the prescription drugs, are being advertised on national television. I am sure the industry sees the tremendous profits to be made with these vitamin, mineral, and herbal products. However, the consumer profits, too, from this availability. A substantial percentage of our population is seeing alternative health practitioners and taking nutritional supplements. Conventional medicine is adapting to these changing times as so many people are looking for something that works and is reasonable in price. Several years ago I was on a radio health talk show of a very prominent nationally known host. Again this past year I met with a well-known man, who is a producer of numerous outstanding books and a national health magazine. He was considering an article about me in his magazine. With both I encountered the same problem. Each wished for me to address a disease. I did my best to explain that I no longer look at a patient as a disease but as a whole person. The radio talk show became a bit heated. The magazine publisher apparently could not find a subject from me for his publication. I had offered him CREDIBLE MEDICINE but he never published it. It was published in SYNAPSE and also in THE TOWNSEND LETTER FOR DOCTORS AND PATIENTS. (Reprints available upon request.) I had a number of e-mail and snail mail letters and telephone calls of praise for this article. It conveys this holistic approach. As I write this article about breast cancer, please bear the above in mind. It becomes necessary to focus on the specific subject to raise health consciousness. I believe that wellness as well as illness begins with the thought process coupled with the feelings, emotions and belief systems. Thoughts create. All thoughts are prayers and God answers our prayers. If we combine our positive thoughts with loving emotions and feelings we manifest health, joy and happiness. Conversely, with the thoughts plus the emotions such as anger, fear, hate, resentment, illness presents. Sometimes, we may be unaware or unconscious of our thoughts and wonder why and what we have created in our reality of life. On the physical plane, we also have factors that may contribute to our illnesses. Without gong into any detail we are looking at the pollution of the air, food and water with all kinds of toxic contaminants that we, in turn, may pollute our bodies. Degenerative diseases are multi factorial. In regard to the Faces of Breast Cancer, let me now turn to the discussion of synthetic bras, restricted lymphatic drainage and other factors in breast cancer that include the Zeta Potential.
SYNTHETIC BRAS Beginning in the mid 1970s I began attending weekend seminars of John Diamond, M.D. in New York City. At that time he was President of the International Academy of Preventive Medicine and founder of Behavioral Kinesiology (BK), a simple form of muscle testing. His initial book on this subject is called BK-BEHAVIORAL KINESIOLOGY and the subsequent paperback, still available, YOUR BODY DOESN’T LIE. I often recommend this book to my patients and to health professionals. It is not only informative but practical for one to apply the various testing techniques with a partner. Back then I was becoming very interested in my hobby of magic. In Ft. Lauderdale’s SearsTown, right near Paul Diamond’s Magic Store, I purchased two large cup synthetic fabric bras. My mother-in-law Mary was kind enough to do the alteration and make a three-cup bra. Now, in doing health talks I began combining a few magic tricks for attention, impact, and educational value. I would call a man up to help me. Next, place the bra on him, often as cameras flashed and many laughed. Then I would do the kinesiology or muscle testing. I would have the person place with his fingers together the middle finger of his right hand on the angle of Louis. This is a bony bump about two inches down from the top of the sternum or breastbone. Go ahead and feel it on yourself. It is the acupuncture alarm point for the thymus gland, the "Commanding General" of our Immune System. Then, I’d have him extend his left upper extremity to the side and parallel to the floor. I’d place my right hand on his left wrist and my left hand on his right shoulder to steady him for the next move. I would ask him to resist my push as I pushed gently and firmly downward and down his arm would go. Next, I’d repeat the test without the bra and the arm would be strong. This testing shows that the synthetic bra interferes with the energy related to the thymus and the immune system. The synthetic fabric creates a electrostatic field that is foreign to the human body and probably detrimental! I can infer from this testing that the synthetic bra is a factor in immuno suppression, and an impaired immune system is a factor in cancer of the breast or of other parts of the body. Solution! I advise my female patients to go for 100% cotton bras. Many of the large department stores have them and I also have a list of sources to order via catalog. (It is available upon request.) If the man is wearing metal-framed glasses or a big metal western belt buckle, I have him remove these items. Metal crossing the midline of the body (right down through the center) causes a condition called "switching." When a person is switched there is to some degree impairment of memory concentration, balance, coordination and receptivity. The switching also reverses the results with the muscle testing. A metal reinforcement in the bra is metal crossing the midline. It results in switching and the above potential problems. So, ladies, avoid the metal in your bras and go for 100% cotton. I learned how to test the thymus and for the switching from Dr. Diamond. For more information go for YOUR BODY DOESN’T LIE.
RESTRICTED LYMPHATIC FLOW/OTHER FACTORS Four years ago I was visiting in Naples, Florida a friend of two decades. We went shopping at the local Barnes and Noble Bookstore for the book, DRESSED TO KILL: The Link Between Breast Cancer and Bras. My friend has the habit at the end of the day at home to do a little magic act like pulling the rabbit out of the hat. Instead, she would reach behind her back and under her blouse and magically produce her bra along with a great shy of relief! I didn’t associate her action with the book until this past weekend when I finished reading this 192 page masterpiece by Sydney Ross Singer with his wife Soma Grismaijer (S/S). Initially, I read the first forty pages and found the bookmark there when I resumed this weekend. I was prompted to write this article by several e-mails from Geoffrey Sherman of the U.K. He is a health enthusiast that sends out via e-mail information about cancer. He is focused on the writings of G. Edward Griffin’s WORLD WITHOUT CANCER (Part I and II) - books that I have had and read twenty years ago, and the use of laetrile for the treatment of patients with cancer. I have sent him my article CREDIBLE MEDICINE to raise his consciousness to a broader focus on degenerative diseases being multi factorial. To the best of my knowledge laetrile is outlawed in the United States. Well, I reviewed the book and made five pages of notes. I have always had a problem with book reviews in that I wish to tell the story of the entire book in a condensed version. So, I encourage you to obtain a copy. I shall weave in some of the highlights with my applicable knowledge. (Avery Publishing Group ISBN 0-89529-664-0 $11.95) Once again there are many factors in why a female develops breast cancer. The disease is multi factorial. I am not primarily concerned with what is the "cause" but with what are the "causes" or "factors," and how they can me eliminated, reduced or controlled. The theory that S/S present is that the constriction of the flow of lymph is a/the (?) cause of breast cancer. As anthropologists, S/S write in a very clear, understandable, yet scientifically credible style. The book opens with the couple doing research in the Fiji Islands with Soma discovering a lump in her breast. As S/S kept me in suspense about her lump until the end of the book, I shall do the same to you and encourage your reading it. The lymphatic drainage to the breast (See page 77) is primarily (85%) to the armpit or axilla; secondarily, to the breastbone area and the liver. The majority of breast cancers are in the upper outer quadrant that is nearest the axilla. The bra is likely to constrict the flow of lymph, concentrate toxins in the breast and contribute to the development to tumors (mass of tissue like a cyst) and cancer (malignant mass of tissue). Most are familiar with the circulatory system with arteries and veins but some may not know much about the lymphatics. This system is a "garbage collector," "disposal" and immune enhancer for the body. The lymph gathers up poisons in the fluid outside the cells and carries it through its vessels and lymph nodes, immune cell manufacturing centers, to be excreted by the other components of the circulation. In addition, many women have red bra strap depressions on their shoulders — another indication of constriction. Some suffer from neurological problems with numbness in the upper extremities and shoulder pain. S/S point out other constricting garments. The high-healed shoes may cause back and hip problems, bunions and hammer toes. As I learned from John Diamond, the high heels also "switch" the cerebral hemispheres of the brain. (See "switching," above.) (I wear and recommend Birkenstock sandals! Source: FOOTPRINTS 1339 Massachusetts Lawrence, KS 66044 1-800-488-8316) Tight fitting men’s underwear may raise the scrotum to nearer the body, increase the temperature and contribute to infertility. Female blended or synthetic panties and panty hose may create a favorable moist hot atmosphere for the "fungus among us," Candida albicans, to thrive with resultant vaginitis with itch and the odorous cottage cheese discharge. Like the bras, tight belts, tight fitting glasses over the bridge of the nose and constricting headpieces as bands and hats may impair lymphatic flow and drainage. Tight belts may play a role in testicular and pelvic cancers such as the bladder, ovaries, uterus and lower intestines. S/S question lymphatic obstruction from tight fitting eyeglass frames over the bridge of the nose. From my BK training with John Diamond, I am aware and can demonstrate that tight fitting hats or headbands weaken the body’s energy. Actually the skull bones "breathe" or move rhythmically and the tightening prevents this natural subtle function. Add tight men’s collars and neckties. It’s enough to choke you. I rarely wear a necktie and never a tightly buttoned shirt. Fortunately, the female corsets are no longer in fashion and may have contributed from the abdominal constriction to skeletal deformities and diseases, as previously mentioned. According to S/S the major breast cancer risk factors are age, country of origin, alleged hormone influence, genetic, diet, toxins and their addition, bras. For details refer to their book. However, let me list a few examples with most from the book with credit to Jeremy Green’s GREEN LIFESTYLE GUIDE: Americans use an average of twenty-five gallons of hazardous wastes/chemicals a year. Car - antifreeze, oil. Household - cleaners for the oven, sink, toilet, drains, degreasers, rust solvents, paints, lawn and garden products - fertilizers, pesticides, herbicides; nail polish remover, shoe polish, glues; irradiated foods, genetically modified foods that the government is not telling us about; artificial colorings and flavorings. Benzene is in photo supplies, spot removers and some solvents. Toxins may be leached from plastic containers or wrappings with microwaving. Formaldehyde out gases from plywood, e.g. in mobile homes. Nitropyrenes are in toners. Toxic waste dumps are polluting the air, ground and aquifer. Gasoline exhaust, radiation, and subtle energies from the earth, electrical appliances, high-tension wires, and cell phones pose still another threat to our health and life. And on and on. I am sure you get the picture! Let me call to your attention the writings of Hulda Clark: especially her book THE CURE FOR ALL CANCERS. She believes that intestinal parasites called flukes are present in our bowel. The presence of various chemicals like benzene, mentioned above, open the door to our body through the circulatory system for the flukes to go to various organs tissues and glands like the liver. As they go through their life cycle within our body a toxic state is created that leads some cells to go crazy with division and "bingo" cancer! I shall briefly focus on two toxins. There is an ever-increasing pollution of our air, food and water (the macrocosm) and subsequently our bodies (the macrocosm). As we become aware of these contaminants we can often take positive loving action to eliminate, reduce or control their poisoning us. The majority of my new patients have been using antiperspirant deodorants that contain aluminum. Several years ago I had a Thai deodorant stone, purchased at a local health food store, analyzed by Doctors Data of Chicago for aluminum. It was loaded. I wrote up the results in the holistic heath magazine HEALTH CONSCIOUSNESS and strongly advised the readers as well as my patients to avoid these stones and antiperspirants with aluminum even though the Thai stone distributor’s medical doctor claimed that this type of aluminum was not harmful. Aluminum has no known role in the human body. It is a poison! Go to natural deodorants or a colloidal silver spray. (See Zeta Potential below) I would estimate that about 95% of the American population has or has had silver or mercury amalgam fillings. Even if the fillings are removed and replaced my clinical observations show me that the patients continue to harbor this toxic substance in their organs, tissues and glands. The mercury travels from the fillings all over the body and causes havoc that is often unrecognized and diagnosed by the physician or dentist. How much mercury is entrapped in the breast tissue and contributes to cancer? We know that the mercury also impairs the function of the immune system as well as other endocrine glands. Clinically, I’d place the mercury toxicity secondary to the fillings on a par with the bras as a major factor in breast cancer, other cancers, and degenerative diseases. Let me highlight for you the Bra and Breast Cancer Study (BBC) that S/S conducted. For the thorough outline, discussion and conclusions refer to their book! On a limited budget of $20,000 and with the help of volunteers, S/S conducted their study from May 1991 to November 1993 in five major U.S. cities — San Francisco, Denver, Phoenix, Dallas and New York. They studied over 4,500 women with about one half having breast cancer. They used a questionnaire (in the book) and personal interviews. Although findings are rather complex here is the essence of the study. Females wanting to avoid breast cancer, wear bras for the shortest time possible with less than twelve hours a day being strongly recommended. Even better, don’t wear a bra! Braless women rarely develop breast cancer. Without wearing a bra there is a twenty fold less chance of developing breast cancer. The push up bras with under wires are tight fitting with resultant pressure and damage. Also, the bra metal crossing the midline of the body causes switching (See above for "switching"). S/S gives directions for the female to determine the proper bra size. They make lifestyle change suggestions. Eat less meat, poultry and fish. I’ll add eliminate pork! Buy organic beef. Use filtered water. Be aware that the skin absorbs chemicals that may be in new clothes, laundry detergents, perfumes, dyes, synthetic fabrics, Spandex in bras and undergarments — fibers contain a chemical compound that may cause skin problems with depigmentation or whitening. Use natural fabrics - cotton, linen and wool. I had silk! You can buy cotton bras (See above.). Learn to massage your breasts after bra removal. Have or develop a more PMA or a Positive Mental Attitude. In the final pages, S/S state they have sent their findings to the "experts" but not one responded. I counted nine! These people consist of prominent health professionals affiliated with well known health organizations of the United States. I can well identify with such a lack of communication throughout my medical career and especially as the Editor/Publisher of HEALTH CONSCIOUSNESS magazine. Years ago when I hosted a local health talk radio show Gene Burns told us that only five percent of those listening call in but the rest are listening! My hunch is that even though only a few or none respond there are many out there getting your message, Sydney and Soma! May God bless you and may this article on Breast Cancer further serve to get the word out and to raise health consciousness about this devastating disease.
ZETA POTENTIAL About the same time as I purchased DRESSED TO KILL a friend of mine from Port St. Lucie, Florida, Frank Hartman, sent me his article PREVENTION AND REVERSAL OF BREAST CANCER, HEART AND DEGENERATIVE DISEASES. (Frank Hartman 2421 Leithgow Street Pert St. Lucie, FL 34952) I have pulled the article from my file and will share with you some of the highlights particularly related to breast cancer. Zeta Potential (ZP) deals with an area of chemistry that has been overlooked and can explain and reverse degenerative disease. ZP is the ability of a liquid to carry material in suspension. Such solutions are called colloids. A well known one in the health field is colloidal silver. Small microscopic particles (less than 0.5 microns) are suspended in a solution by a minute electrical charge, the ZP. Milk and blood are two examples of very stable colloidal solutions. Aluminum (Al) destroys ZP. Al is used in city water that is cloudy to precipitate out particles to clear the water. Yet, the Al remains for the consumer. Al is often the primary component in deodorants and body lotions that women frequently apply after a shower with shaving the under arm hair and legs. With the warm porous skin absorption is increased. Another harmful substance is the high salt diet from the shaker and in highly processed foods. Salt (NaCl) destroys the ZP, too! As one ages there is a decrease in the blood ZP with subsequent kidney overload. There is increased precipitation of toxins and toxic metals in parts of the body that include the breasts as well as joints, limbs, extremities and the blood vessels. Remember, the axilla where the antiperspirant is applied is right next to the upper outer quadrant of the breast, which has the highest number of cancers. So, when the female applies the aluminum antiperspirant, the ZP is zapped and the toxins precipitate out into the breast tissue. (In medical school we observed in some patients a dark pigmentation near the optic nerve but were not taught what it was from lack of knowledge. Years later I learned from Hal Huggins, DDS that the pigmentation is actually mercury tattoos coming from the fillings in the teeth. I question if anyone has studied pigmentation in cancerous breast tissue for mercury, aluminum and other toxic metals.) Frank recommends avoidance of aluminum in any form - cookware, cans, some antacids, and especially Al containing deodorants and body lotions. For alternatives read the labels before you purchase. He mentions Mennen Crystal Clear Deodorant, Jergens Advanced Therapy Aloe Enriched Skin Lotion, and Natures Family and Sesame Oil (applied in the shower). I use Nature’s Gate herbal deodorants (all natural) and /or colloidal silver that kill the bacteria that cause the body odor. Drink distilled water, six glasses a day. You may add black cherry concentrate for taste and surface tension. Carrot juice has the lowest surface tension of the vegetables and is a fine source of calcium. He also suggests other fresh organic vegetable juices. Eliminate or reduce salt from the diet. Frank is an advocate of chelation therapy for removal of toxic metals from the body. (Contact me for further information.) Well, readers, guess what? Yes, that’s the end, well almost. Let me add that although rare, men also get breast cancer. Many of the above recommendations are applicable for the male! ... And just as I finish I received from the Harris Organization (11/2/99) that according to government statistics, each year 35,000 men in the United States die from prostate cancer while 43,000 women die of breast cancer. Let’s put the accent first on prevention of cancer and then the early detection!
ROY. B. KUPSINEL, M.D. Dr. Kupsinel graduated from Tufts University in 1949 and the University of Miami School of Medicine in 1959. For eleven years he practiced family medicine in Hallandale, Florida and then he spent three years in Emergency Medicine in the Orlando area. In 1975 he entered an evolving private practice of holistic medicine. He is the Director of the Lost Horizon Health Awareness Center in Oviedo, Florida. Dr. Kupsinel has been a member of many of the pioneering organizations in preventive and alternative medicine. He is Past International President of the Society of American Magicians and often combines magic with his presentations. For fifteen years he was editor and publisher of HEALTH CONSCIOUSNESS magazine. He has been making numerous national and international appearances on radio and television and at medical and health meetings. ROY B. KUPSINEL, M.D.
Naturopathy, New Products &
Reseach
By: Marlene Prendeville Some healthcare providers may have forgotten that people are individuals, not robots. World renowned speakers shared their knowledge and experience in medicine at the ANMA’s 21st annual convention held recently at the Riviera Hotel-Casino, Las Vegas. The ANMA is the nation’s oldest and largest American Association of Naturopathic Physicians. New clinical research and products were presented, along with methods to achieve optimum success in treatment. The conference was larger this year in attendance and exhibitor booths. "This was a better show. ANMA brings together manufacturers and health practitioners so that manufacturers can review their latest products and teach practitioners how to treat patients with natural products," said Dr. Leslie Taylor of Raintree. The seminars, provided excellent continuing medical education. Dr. Jennifer Nissen of Lane Labs, who once considered a career in conventional medicine said: "When I discovered naturopathic medicine, I realized it embodied everything I believed in. Through naturopathy, I am able to make a scientific connection between natural products and their beneficial effects on human health." Sally Byrd, Nutritional Supplement Manager at Tree of Life Inc. added: "As a ANMA member, board certified naturopath, and licensed body worker, I look forward to attending this conference every year." ANMA subscribe to the motto "Doctor do no harm". Members state they have a strong commitment to the philosophy, art and science of natural therapeutics. "As a naturopath we work with all natural substances and we do not use any prescription drugs which have a lot of side effects. ANMA members do not believe in doing surgery as a naturopathic practitioner," said Dr. Raj Pal, President of the California Chapter, who provides supplements through Royal Nutrition: Policosanol sugar derived substitute that helps lower LDL cholesterol, and raises HDL cholesterol. (800-524-3727). "Becoming certified in CPR, was another plus for this conference," said Sally Byrd. "The ANMA did a great job. I appreciate the preparatory work as well as the legal work on our behalf that is part of ANMA’s daily routine." Byrd said she was hooked on using Jill’s Energy Boots (Modern Reflexology ) and is now the proud owner of a pair. "It’s a great way to relieve the stresses of everyday life and provide your patients with added benefits!" ANMA’s educational convention offers an opportunity to meet colleagues, and form valuable supportive friendships with others sharing your views. Hot topics: Non-Insulin Dependent Diabetes Melitis Type II: Dr. Wm Shell’s Alternative treatment protocols. Faulty Brain by Dr. Robert Marshall who, in 1969, when faced with a near fatal, undiagnosable illness that failed to respond to medical treatment, designed his own nutritional program that resulted in full recovery. Understanding Modern Dentistry – The Do’s and Don’ts; Holistic Iridology – new perspectives on an Ancient Practice; New Strategies in Cancer Application; Homeopathic Endocrinology/Hormone Rejuvenation; Tools in Cancer Treatment/Prevention; Clear the Whole Body Toxin Burden; Toxic Bile Syndrome; Luncheon Speaker, Dr. Dennis A Robbins, addressing many of the thorny issues in American Health care. Raintree Nutrition Inc. offered a variety of support formulas, herb capsules, prosexual products, tinctures and extracts. "Raintree’s practitioner products are a group of organ specific support products, cytotoxic and antimicrobial formulas," said Dr. Leslie Taylor. Leading products: Graviola (plant for Cancer) and N-Tense (combination of Graviola with five other cytotoxic plants); Joint Muscle Support for Arthritis; Muira Puama natural Amazonian aphrodisiac plants and plant formulas; Multi herb for men, including Muira Puama; Clavo Huasca (Vine) leading femal libido stimulant. Raintree’s retail line in health food stores (800-780-5902). Lane Labs, an industry leader in unique products, introduced Toki, an anti-wrinkle formula, Viracle seaweed supplement to support healthy lip-skin tissue, and anti-aging skin rejuvenators. "Toki is a collagen replacement drink that enhances skin from within. One great benefit of oral collagen is that it improves the quality of skin over the entire body. The collagen in Toki is a processed, low molecular weight collagen that is easily absorbed thorough the intestines, into the bloodstream," said Dr. Jennifer Nissen Manager of Nutrition Research. Toki is great for women because it contains a full day’s supply of 3A calcium, that has been shown to increase bone mineral density. Additionally, it contains glucosamine, which has been proven to diminish joint pain. In an eight-week clinical trial, women experienced a significant subjective and objective improvement in periorbital wrinkles and overall aging. They also had a mean increase of blood collagen levels of over 114%, signifying effective absorption of collagen. Many baby boomers who attended the convention said they were willing to be guinea-pigs for Toki. Lane’s excellent product MGN3 is made from a combination of powerful Asian mushrooms. "MGN3 is made for the body to boost its natural immune system. I have had patients who suffer from Lyme disease, chronic fatigue, adrenal stress, diabetes and weakened immune systems faithfully using this product," said Sally Byrd. Lane’s 3A Calcium and Advocal are big winners, proven clinically to build critical bone mass during hormonal changes. Seaweed, common to Asian countries, a powerful super food for skin & hormonal health, is one of nature’s natural antioxidants. The combination of using the MGN3, the 3A Calcium and the seaweed products will help your bone strength, skin, wound healing, and immune support that provides a natural balance to your everyday life. (Lane 800-526-3001/www.888ageless.com) Most people do not get enough magnesium in their diet. Ionic Liquid Magnesium, the miracle mineral distributed by MMI Labs proves that magnesium is so essential for many maladies to be corrected and to help maintain good health and cardiac balance. "It does help my bones and allows for much better sleep," said one visitor to the booth. That fact can be seen from a seminar given by Dr. Roger Gunderson. "In my explanation to those attending, I was in the process of explaining how well our product is absorbed and how our ionic form magnesium helps relax muscles and get rid of cramps, and before I had finished that part of my presentation, one of the attendees raised her hand and said, I have had a spasm in my back for weeks and no matter how much magnesium I have taken to relax, none seemed to work. MMI’s Ionic Magnesium has worked in less than one minute". "Over the past year since our Ionic Magnesium was released, many people got rid of cramps, especially leg and menstrual cramps. We are talking about patients diagnosed by their MD with restless legs etc., they are astonished at the rapid results". Dr. Gunderson said he also discovered a new way to administer Vitamin C facially, via a new delivery system in spray from. This new product should change the way people use facial products such as vitamin C. "I enjoyed Dr. Gunderson’s seminar. I have been an avid magnesium user for 25 years. This seminar was validation of facts that I have been practicing and preaching about, and for patients who require higher doses of magnesium and who do not desire the laxative-like effects of the tablets this is a lifesaver," said Sally Byrd. Ionic magnesium is available in liquid, powder and concentrated form. 90% of all Americans are deficient in this powerful mineral — with deficiencies linked to the most prevalent disease in the US — heart disease, osteoporosis, diabetes, depression and stress. (888-775-7456/www.mag-i-cal.com) No more probing and guesswork about acupuncture points or meridian placements. Visitors were impressed with the QXCI system. Sally Byrd enthused about the ease and convenience of combining various biofeed back processes through one computer system. "Just put on your headband, strap in your ankles and wrists and the computer does all the work for you! I sat amazed, as my spine slowly adjusted itself over a 30 minute session." (800-494-2086) Duane Davis demonstrated the Bio Meridian Stress Assessment System that provides extraordinary new perspectives on the state of the body’s energetic health and balance. "Testing patients for allergies and chemical exposure, this technology has enabled us to do this and far more," Davis said (801-501-7517). He discussed QpunctureII Acupuncture technology and art from Jong Lee (213-427-2555). Feel the Chi and expand your knowledge about green, oolong tea varieties. Visitors spent much time in the tea seminar/booth. Many said they were converted to high-quality loose teas from Dr. Brenton Harvey, Acupuncturist, Chinese Herbalist from Denver, CO. His wife Hong, (a Tai Chi & Qi Gong instructor) owns the superior quality Chinese Tea Imports. Taking Bovine Colostrum is another way to boost your immune system while taking food products from a natural source. PROSymbiotics’ Colostrum, the perfect dietary supplement, high-quality Bovine Colostrum, the ultimate Immune System Modulator, for most including people with intestinal & digestive problems (especially leaky gut syndrome). Colostrum is being used to regulate metabolism and to create lean muscle mass. As we age muscle strength and insulin resistance is key to a long healthy life-style. Research reveals that Colostrum supplementation provides anti-aging properties and is being used to regulate blood sugar levels and mood swings. Unlock the body’s self-healing power with the portable LumaLight, advanced color therapy reflexology to regulate your energy flow. Spectrahue Light & Sound Inc. (416-340-0882). Color therapy is being used in many facets of life from hospitals to prisons, and it is also entering the salons-spas with some clinical applications. Sally Byrd had the opportunity to receive a ‘Color Facial’ at the show. "Although skeptical at first, I was amazed to ‘feel’ different levels of calming and relaxation taking place during the treatment. I was a little light-headed afterwards but immensely re-energized." Live blood cell analysis from Dr. Ariel Aentara, at the Innerlight booth designed to deliver antiseptics into deep pockets (800-533-1821) Dr. Janet and Tom Wu taught attendees how to work White Flower Chinese Analgesic Balm herbal balm into stressed areas of the body and feet. The non-greasy balm is a pain reliever for sports, massage therapists, anyone with aches, sore muscles, headaches, sinus, asthma, insect bites, allergies. The essential oils of lavender-eculayptus induce a calming sensation while penetrating the skin. A dot on the temple will relieve a headache. People with sinus may feel relief from using small amounts of balm on the hand and vigorously rubbing both hands together then breathe-in deeply. Dr. Tom Wu, P.O. Box 1111, Belmont, CA 94002 Dr. Paul Thomason, Herbal Research, displayed his excellent products: Candida KD2, Fibromyalgia, Endometriosis/related infertility (sales@hriltd.com/011-44-189-252-8628). Dr. Robert Thiel, Doctors Research, conducted clinical trials for patients with ADD/ADHD, allergies, arthritis, chronic fatigue, infections, fibromyalgia, migraines, musculoskeletal pain, thyroid problems (805-489-7185). It is not always easy to pick the real winners in today’s proliferation of nutritional products, but Tree of Life award winning products top the list: Eye Care Support, Super Multivitamins; Iron-free Super Multi; 50+ Multi; Menopause Support; CoQ10 for heart circulation and immune function; Vegetarian Daily Digestive Enzymes; Full Spectrum Enzymes to promote optimum digestive support; Super EFA Complex for the maintenance of cell formulation, skin and nerve health and Heart Support EFA to support a healthy heart and cardiovascular system; B-50 Complex for stress, poor dietary habits, environmental conditions, alcohol, smoking, hormonal changes and other health challenges that often deplete your body of these key nutrients. Tree of Life also provide numerous other supplements and a range of organic frozen vegetables. Tree of Life (800-260 2424). NaturalCare has uniquely combined the life-regeneration of Nutraceuticals with the healing power of homeopathic medicines – the result: Dr. Bob Martin’s HearAll, that supports hearing, sharpens hearing clarity and protects delicate hearing cells from damage. RingSTOP is a new, high-potency homeopathic-butrceutical remedy that prevents ringing. In America alone some 50 million people suffering from tinnitus. Dr. Bob’s OptiAll is the most advanced, complete good vision and eye health product available. OptiAll-Carnosine, Lutein, Alpha Lipoic Acid, and Bilberry, along with standardized phyto-nutrients and essential vitamins and minerals protect the eyes from damage associated with aging. Spinach and Kale support good vision (1-800-475-3100). Carrington Laboratories Inc., the ISO 9001-certified, research-based biopharmaceutical company has been awarded the "Certified Organic" designation by Costa Rica’s Eco-LOGICA. The rating means that the raw material which is the basis of all Carrington products and those marketed by its subsidiary, Caraloe Inc., has met stringent guidelines for organic production. Caroloe markets consumer products under the AloeCeuticals brand and also sells raw material such as Manapol Immune Enhancing, Stress Reducing, Hydrapol and Manapol Plus. "The new "Certified Organic’ rating that meets international standards, reassures consumers and the products of other manufacturers who use our raw materials that they are receiving truly organically grown goods," said Walt C Jones, president of Caraloe Inc. Carrington-Caraloe markets bulk ingredients from Aloe Vera L. utilizing patented complex carbohydrate technology. Carrington also manufacture and market products for as its patented GelSite controlled drug-delivery technology now under development. (www.carringtonlabs.com/800-527-5216/972-518-1300). (www.mannatech.com) Other new products: Mediral International’s natural product, Psy-Dem for the early stages of dementia (877-633-4725). GY&N Pharmacology’s Neuro Homocystinex for dementia, brain cell regeneration; Hyperhomocysteinemia for elevated levels of plasma Homocysteine associated with coronary heart disease caused by genetic/life-style (800-526-3030). Osteo-Plex (877-864-5112). American Longevity’s Ultimate Sweeteze Diabetes prevention and support (800-982-3189). Professional Complementary Health Formulas Cardio Clear specialty ingredients and Ayurvedic herbs blended in a synergistic vitamin/mineral base; Buffered Vitamin C Ascorbate capsules (800-952-2210). Increase Libido with Ayurceutics Herbal TriBull for men; Shatavari herb capsules for women; Pegasus for stress and mental stamina (800-994-2987). Vita Vision’s age-related macular degeneration pill, manufactured for US Oftalmi, Florida (508-922-4971). Akorn’s I-Sense OcuShield Kyteub & Zeaxanthin (800-932-5676). Nature’s Dream Diet Enzyme Botanika Extract vitamins, minerals, Omega 3-6-9 rids the body of excess water, Vigor+ (800-897-2300/626-339-0120). Herbalenium Innovative Pancreas Tonic (626-963-4220). Blessed Herb’s Internal Cleansing kit to cleanse and rejuvenate 10 organs and systems: digestive, colon, liver, gallbladder, kidney, lung, bladder, blood, skin, Lymphatic from Master Herbalist Martha Volcho (800-489-4372). The highly advanced Colon Hydrotherapy Aquanet EC-2000 and Colonet JR-4 for professional and home use (604-929-7019/800-223-9374). Revitalize your life with Sun Chlorella single-cell freshwater green algae capsules; Pet Sun Chlorella for your pet’s health and vitality (800-829-2828) Dr. Linda Freeland’s Supergreens: 49 different organic grasses, vegetables, sprouted grains and leaves to nourish your cells (937-372-9777) Save your Teeth! Avoid Gum surgery, use the VitaPick high quality applicator (800-533-1821). To avoid Root Canals, Mercury and Metals try Laser for ultimate health at the Center for Advanced Dentistry, Fullerton, California (714-870-0310). We Care Holistic Health invited attendees to their Palm Springs Resort, for classes: Colon Cleansing and Detoxification, high enzymatic diet, skin brushing, detox baths, breathing, yoga, creative dance, and more (800-888-2523). Dr. Joel Wallach’s Ultimate all-in-one liquid supplement; Ultimate vitamins, minerals, antioxidants and Majestic Earth Char Murphy (800-969-9272). Tapes: "Dead Doctors Don’t Lie." "Live Doctors Do Lie." Visit Desert Hot Springs Aqua Caliente, Palm Springs (800-423-8100). On sale, twice Nobel Prize Winner, Linus Pauling’s Heart Disease Video (800-894-9025). The incredible shrinking woman Mary Jane Medlock told an interesting story about her weight loss using Young’s Medifast diet with SuperGreens Tea (972-617-5094). Become healthy once again, read Sick & Tired; Back to the House of Health with rejuvenating recipes to alkalize and energize life. Authors Robert & Shelley Redford Young. The pH Miracle, obese people do not have a fat problem but an acidity problem, by Dr. Robert Young. Woodland Publishing (801-785-8100/800-777-2665). Attending the convention, Kathleen Carrera, owner Custom Beauty: "For the first time you can have all your favorite makeup colors in one refillable purse-size compact using natural Gemstone Mineral Makeup, micromilled Crystal Silica, natural sunscreen SPF 17-20 from Titanium Dioxide and Zinc Oxide (888-830-2183). For Information on the next ANMA Convention, July 18,19,20, 2003: Tel: 702-897-7053 or www.anma.com Marlene Prendeville is a member of the International Federation of Journalists. She has an MBA from London University and a Masters from Trinity. She may be contacted at: 534 Tam O’Shanter Drive
A Call For Validated Research Papers Dealing With Alternative/Naturopathic Health Care ANMA members and other health care professionals are invited to submit an article or case study to be featured in the ANMA Monitor. Your research must be submitted according to the following standards: The ANMA Monitor is published quarterly by ANMA, P.O. Box 96273, Las Vegas, Nevada 89193 (702) 897-7053. Deadlines for ar | ||||||
